Rank 'em: The <i>Halloween</i> Franchise Films

Rank 'em: The Halloween Franchise Films

What better way to celebrate Halloween than by revisiting every single one of the Halloween franchise films? That's just what I've been doing all month long, so you know what that means: I'm a little punchy at this point and it's time to rank 'em.

A few spoilers lie ahead, of course.

10. and 9. Halloween (2007) and Halloween II (2009)

"Gotta get back to the pole, Michael. Mommy's busy providin' for you trash-heap hillbillies."

I'm lumping together the two Rob Zombie reboots because, frankly, they're equally bad. Zombie added a stereotypical Zombie touch to the franchise lore—Michael Myers' family was pure white trash! Michael's mom was an exotic dancer! Dr. Loomis once looked like an old, dirty hippie!—but almost none of it worked, nor was any of it even necessary. Instead, it took what made the taut and lean original so good and bloated it into something unrecognizable. I'm a fan of Zombie's House of a 1,000 Corpses and The Devil's Rejects, but the less said about these two films the better.

8. Halloween: Resurrection (2002)

Technically, this is probably inferior to either of Zombies' attempts, but we're really splitting hairs with these bottom three films; they're all terrible. This one's also an abomination, a crime against both Jamie Lee Curtis and all of humanity, for Anti-Christ's sake. She finished off Mikey in the previous film (chopped his Shatner-masked head off, in fact), and that should have been the fitting end to her story. Nope, instead, she's summarily killed off early in this film (by her Boogeyman brother, of course), and then everything really careens right off the rails. Resurrection is a steaming pile of garbage.

7. Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995)

Loomis is so single-minded that he doesn't even notice the baby Rudd's holding.

This one's an utter mess. I know there's a "producer's cut" that's (supposedly) marginally better, but please. Even a young and heroic Paul Rudd can't save this turkey. Poor Donald Pleasence as Loomis seems worn out by it all. In fact, he'd die shortly after filming his scenes. It's yet another crime against humanity that this is how he went out. Shameful.

6. Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later (1998)

This was the big one, twenty years after John Carpenter's Halloween. Finally, the return of Jamie Lee Curtis to the role of Laurie Strode. And that's about all I have to say about it. It's fine, but mostly dull. Sure, it's nice to see Jamie Lee back in action, this time trying to save her son (Josh Hartnett and his permanently mussed hair) and herself from Michael, but none of it really feels of a piece with the previous films in the franchise. That said, the film that followed, Resurrection, makes H20 look like Citizen Kane.

5. Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989)

Tina definitely survived Halloween 5. I'm positive. Her neon heart protected her.

We've reached the cream of the crop now. Each film in my top five is near and dear to my heart, for highly specific reasons. Revenge is to Return as II is to the original—the action picks up only months after the end of Return, with young Jamie Lloyd (Danielle Harris) recovering from the traumatic events of the previous film. Most importantly, this is the film that gave us the cinematic treasures Tina Williams (Wendy Kaplan) and her heart made of neon. She is without question the most divisive characters in the series, which mostly mystifies me. She's a vibrant, life-affirming presence in a franchise firmly rooted in death. I'm firmly Team Tina, and will argue her merits with anyone, any time.

4. Halloween II

It's hard to rank this one lower than the two that follow, but for as much as I love this sequel, the sheer craziness and audacity of the next two films on the list win out for me. Laurie (Jamie Lee Curtis) spends much of the film convalescing in a bizarrely quiet and nearly empty hospital while Michael rampages through the halls, boiling people alive in hot tubs or jamming hypodermic needles in their eyes. You know, just up to his usual antics. The kills in this sequel, however, are from Rick Rosenthal are far more gruesome than in Carpenter's original. Again, these first two films of the franchise act as a wonderfully cohesive set, with II suffering only in comparison to the unimpeachable greatness of the first film.

3. Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1983)

Is that a mask in your pocket, doctor, or are you just happy to see me?

The black sheep of the Halloween family, the outlier, the only film in the bunch not about Michael Myers. It's such a strange film, with so many disparate and demented plot elements, that its no wonder audiences were mystified by it in 1983. You can't help but love its eccentricities, though—deadly masks, robot clones, a deliciously evil Irish businessman, the absurdly catchy Silver Shamrock jingle, and finally Tom Atkins macking on Stacey Nelkin for god's sake. Unfairly maligned for years, simply because it diverged from the path established in the first two films, III has managed to age pretty well. It's so bonkers, such an acid-trip of nonsensical insanity, that its rightly developed its own rabid fan base, including yours truly.

2. Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988)

In Haddonfield, cops might do it by the book, but their daughters? Not so much.

This was the return to form (after the anomaly that is III), the return of Michael Myers to Haddonfield, where he was now stalking Laurie's daughter, Jamie. This time out, Pleasence is joined by a stellar cast, including Ellie Cornell as our hero Rachel, Sasha Jenson as wannabe playa Brady, and Kathleen Kinmont as smoking hot Kelly. Atmospherically eerie, with moments of true terror and vivid horror, the film is lush and tense, culminating in a twist ending that elicits one of Pleasence's most memorably shouted lines of dialogue—and the man shouted a lot of dialogue over the course of his five Halloween films. Pair it with Revenge and you've got a terrific one-two punch of peak mid-period Halloween. In fact, Return was the last truly great Halloween film, and it was all downhill after Revenge.

1. Halloween (1978)

Still terrifying after all these years.

No surprise, the first is still the very best, by a wide margin. What more can I say about a movie that has been praised for nearly forty years as the forerunner of the modern cinematic horror boom? From the eerie cinematography to the expert pacing to the haunting score to Loomis's fever pitch ("The evil has come to your little town!") and beyond, it's nearly a perfect film. With Halloween, Carpenter created a work against which all future films of its kind will be measured. Most of them will never measure up, though.

*****

The Women of Horrotober: Heather Langenkamp in Wes Craven’s New Nightmare

The Women of Horrotober: Heather Langenkamp in Wes Craven’s New Nightmare

All through the month of October, the After Movie Diner has been running an extravaganza of Halloween-related essays, articles, reviews, and podcast episodes. Today, appropriately, my article about the original Halloween is up. I also contributed seven (!) essays about some of my favorite "Women of Horror", five of which have run as of this writing—Lili Taylor in The Addiction, Laurie Zimmer in Assault on Precinct 13, Shelley Duvall in The Shining, Belinda Balaski in The Howling, and Heather Langenkamp in Wes Craven's New Nightmare. Look for pieces on Carla Gugino in Gerald's Game and Wendy Kaplan in Halloween 5 soon.

Comments

Blowing in the Wind: Marilyn Monroe and That Iconic White Dress

This month marks sixty-five years since one of the most iconic moments in twentieth-century popular culture: Marilyn Monroe’s angelic white dress being blown sky high by wind rushing up from a subway grate beneath her feet in the film The Seven Year Itch . Billy Wilder shot multiple takes, while Sam Shaw snapped photo after photo for what had to be the biggest publicity stunt ever staged at the time. Marilyn wore two pairs of underwear for the shot, yet, as noted in Lois Banner's critical biography Marilyn: The Passion and the Paradox (2012), "a dark blotch of pubic hair" remained visible to the 100 male photographers and over 1,500 male spectators, all of whom crowded eagerly around the set to gawk and drool. Due to strict 1950s movie censorship laws, photos had to be doctored to white out the offending blotch, but those in attendance saw it, over and over, shot after shot. Marilyn's husband at the time, the extremely old fashioned Joe DiMaggio, stormed off th

All I Want For Christmas: Phoebe Cates's Monologue in Gremlins

Joe Dante's 1980s classic Gremlins will always be a subversive Christmas favorite. From Spike exploding in the microwave to Mrs. Daigle's "stairlift to hell", the movie is packed with deliciously transgressive moments that turn the holly jolly season right on its ear. None are more memorable, though, than Phoebe Cates delivering her legendary "worst thing that ever happened to me on Christmas" monologue. It's a jaw-dropping, tour-de-force moment, a truly horrific story that's also one of the most darkly comic moments in Christmas movie history. Cates really shines during this scene. There's no denying just how seminal that scene of hers in Fast Times at Ridgemont High was for a generation of young people, but her speech in Gremlins is equally important and a wonderful showcase for her serious and comedic acting skills. Here's the speech, in its entirety. No Christmas season is complete without at least one viewing

Misspent Youth: Joanne Whalley

Looking back at the pop culture mainstays of this Gen-Xer's gloriously misspent youth. One of the most famous and oft-quoted Seinfeld scenes involves Bobka and Jerry's discovery of the existence of Cinnamon Bobka. After Elaine scoffs at the notion of such a thing, even calling it a "lesser Bobka," Jerry unleashes one of the great defenses of a freshly ground spice ever delivered: People love cinnamon. It should be on tables at restaurants along with salt and pepper. Anytime anyone says, "Oh This is so good. What's in it?" The answer invariably comes back, Cinnamon. Cinnamon. Again and again. Joanne Whalley is like Cinnamon. Yes, I just compulsively double-checked my DVD copy and it's the unrated version, thank you very much. Let me explain. You see, during the formative years of my misspent youth, if I stumbled on a movie featuring the doe-eyed, petite, beautiful English actress, invariably I'd feel like Jerry does about Cin

"That girl looks just like Pat Benatar"

Linda, that girl looks just like Pat Benatar. I know. Wait, there are three girls here at Ridgemont who have cultivated the Pat Benatar look. I was just a kid when Fast Times at Ridgemont High opened in 1982. Still though, even at the tender young age of seven, I knew who Pat Benatar was, because a.) her music was all over the radio and even then I recognized the utter awesomeness of her vocal talent in songs like "Hit Me With Your Best Shot", and b.) some of the older girls around town were obviously cribbing their looks—clothes, hair, makeup, strut—from Benatar's own style. Benatar was ubiquitous. So, when I see or hear vintage-era Benatar now, I think of Fast Times , but mostly I remember that ubiquity—of both the performer and her legion of young imitators. I know it's not true, but when I recollect those years I swear every older girl looked like either Benatar, Juice Newton, or Joan Jett. It's easy to forget, years later, that

Misspent Youth: Randi Brooks

Looking back at the pop culture mainstays of this Gen-Xer's gloriously misspent youth. ***** A note on the series and this site: This might be the final post in the "Misspent Youth" series - at least here. Maybe it'll eventually move with me. Oh, right, I buried the lede: I've moved, and would love for you to come visit me at my new site, The Starfire Lounge ! Moving forward, this site will likely cease to be updated, but will remain around for posterity and your continued reading pleasure. I have a few more things to post here over the coming days or weeks as a sort of "everything must go" send-off to the old girl. I also plan to write a final farewell post to my main online home for the last five years. Stay tuned and, as always, thanks for reading. ***** It's no surprise that the talented but now mostly forgotten Randi Brooks would make an appearance in the Misspent Youth series. She may not be a household name, but her resume

Misspent Youth: Morgan Fairchild

Looking back at the movies, music, television, and other pop culture mainstays of this Gen-Xer's gloriously misspent youth. Once I decided that Morgan Fairchild would be the subject of the next installment in this series, I did what I usually do and researched online for a bit, just to refresh my memory on details that might've previously been lost to time. Morgan Fairchild was legitimately one of the most potent sex symbols of the 1970s and '80s. Not that I needed much refresher when it came to Fairchild. Born Patsy Ann McClenny in Dallas, Texas, February 3, 1950, the American actress was everywhere during those oh-so-crucial formative years of my pop culture obsession. She loomed large in the growing ranks of proto-haughty glamour queens, a trope that was hot on prime time TV in the 1980s. The characters she was most well-known for were drop-dead gorgeous and didn't suffer fools lightly. Really, few ever did it better than Fairchild. The shirt do

It Came From the '90s: My Secret Crush on The Nanny

This series looks back at the 1990s and its influence on the generation of people who came of age during the decade. For six seasons in the 1990s, The Nanny made many of us laugh. At times, it could be downright hilarious . At others, well, not so much . This isn't a review of a '90s sitcom staple, though. No. This is simply an excuse to come clean about something I've kept buried deep inside for over two decades now: I had a secret crush on The Nanny herself, Fran Drescher. The unadulterated nineties-ness of this is practically blinding. And I love it. While The Nanny was sometimes quite funny, thanks largely to Drescher's spunky charisma and wholehearted commitment, the show was never considered hip. People my parents age seemed to love it, but my friends preferred, well, Friends . That smile! Those legs! That dress! It's all overloading my circuits. I watched Friends with my friends, but I also thoroughly enjoyed The Nanny , to

Margot Kidder and the Childhood Crush That Will Never Die

"I dream about sex, flying, and being chased by Nazis." — Margot Kidder, Rolling Stone , "The Education of Margot Kidder", 1981 ***** File that quote under, "Reasons why I love Margot Kidder." Last month, Margot hopped a one-way flight with old pal Chris Reeve off into the stars and beyond, where they could reenact their iconic moment from Superman (1978), for all eternity. I wrote a little about Margot, here and here , trying to explain why this particular actress meant so much to me as a kid growing up in the 1980s. I thought that would be enough. It wasn't.* Those posts were my fumbling attempts to sort out just how large an impact Margot had on my young life, and, to my present-day surprise, how much she still means to me now. Before news of her death, I hadn't thought of her in ages. I assumed the early childhood crush I harbored for my Lois Lane had dwindled and faded. Ha! I was a fool. My crush on Margot was very

It Came From the '90s: Kelly Bundy and the Alternative Family Ideal

This series looks back at the 1990s and its influence on the generation of people who came of age during the decade. Very few television series in the 1990s were as polarizing as Married...with Children . People either loved it or they loathed it. TV critics and good upstanding Catholic families like mine fell into the latter category. Soon after it debuted during my first year of junior high in 1987 (not quite the '90s, but on the brink), my parents made it clear that we would not be watching. I believe the words they used were "vulgar," "unfunny," and, one of their perennial favorites, "risque." Of course, this meant it immediately took on a prurient appeal for me. Parents can never win, honestly. Kelly Bundy—the talented Christina Applegate, who never gets enough credit for elevating the blonde airhead trope into an art form—only further piqued my interest. She was like the girls in school with the absurdly voluminous hair and ridiculously sh

My Favorite Death Dealer: Kate Beckinsale

"I dropped out of Oxford, and now I only speak Russian with the woman who gives me a bikini-wax. See what Hollywood does to you?" "Apparently, I'm very good at firing a gun without blinking, which is unusual. That's why so many action characters have to wear sunglasses during shoot-out scenes. That's my party trick." "Someone once said that you can make the choice between getting old and getting creepy, and I think getting old is the way to go." ***** Before I begin, here's a haiku that took me at least ten seconds to write: Ah, Kate Beckinsale. We'd gladly live with you, in your Underworld Yeah, so, I'm a fan. I've always been a fan of Kate Beckinsale, especially as the vampire Death Dealer Selene in the action/horror franchise Underworld (five films and counting now) and as a young upwardly mobile publishing professional in Whit Stillman's masterpiece of earl

Words Seem Out Of Place

Search This Blog